Zinc Distillation Column Rupture
Horsehead Zinc Refinery Fatal Explosion and Fire
Horsehead Corporation — Monaca Zinc Refinery
📍 Monaca, PA
Incident: July 22, 2010 • CSB Report: March 11, 2015 (technical analysis)
2
Fatalities
1
Seriously Injured
Superheated Liquid Zinc and Zinc Vapor (above 1,600°F)
Chemical / Hazard
0
CSB Recommendations
📋 Incident Summary

On July 22, 2010, a zinc distillation column ruptured inside the refinery building at the Horsehead zinc facility in Monaca, Pennsylvania, about 35 miles north of Pittsburgh. Two operators who were doing unrelated maintenance on a nearby column were killed, and a third operator was seriously injured. Zinc vapor released at high temperature combusts spontaneously in air, creating a massive zinc flame.

A CSB-commissioned technical analysis, released March 11, 2015, found the explosion likely resulted from a buildup of superheated liquid zinc inside the ceramic column, which then explosively decompressed. The column had been started up just 12 days earlier. A partial obstruction of the column sump, which had not been replaced when the column was rebuilt and had a history of drainage problems, likely caused liquid zinc to flood the lower trays.

Ten minutes before the explosion, an alarm sounded. Operators cut the fuel gas but did not reduce the zinc feed, and workers in the building were not warned. The CSB closed the investigation without formal recommendations.

🔎 Key Findings
Finding 01
Column Flooded with Liquid Zinc
A partially obstructed sump likely let liquid zinc build up and flood the lower trays, where it became superheated.
Finding 02
Sump Not Replaced and Problems Not Corrected
The sump was reused when the column was rebuilt, despite drainage problems that had forced the previous column to shut down early.
Finding 03
Design Flaw in the Sump Underflow
The small 65 mm clearance in the sump underflow had been implicated in other zinc column explosions around the world.
Finding 04
Warning Signs Missed
Symptoms of a blocked sump were evident days before. A control room alarm sounded ten minutes before the explosion, but the zinc feed was not reduced and workers were not warned.
Finding 05
Hazards Had Been Normalized
The analysis concluded that hazardous conditions had been normalized. The facility had five documented column explosions before 2010.
🔍 Root Causes
1
Sump obstruction
Solids partially blocked the sump, causing liquid zinc to accumulate in the column.
2
Change in service without adequate review
The reused sump now handled four to five times more liquid flow than before.
3
Normalization of deviance
Known sump problems and prior explosions did not lead to correction.
☑ CSB Recommendations
→ No formal recommendations
The Board voted in January 2015 to close the investigation and released a technical analysis by a zinc distillation expert on March 11, 2015. The facility had been shut down and dismantled.

Full recommendation text and current status: CSB investigation page.

💡 Lessons Learned
Reused equipment must be reviewed for its new service conditions.
Recurring problems, like drainage issues, should be fixed, not worked around.
Alarm response must include steps to remove the energy and feed driving the hazard, and warning people at risk.
Five earlier explosions were warnings that hazards had become normal.
MI: Mechanical IntegritySOP: Operating ProceduresPSSR: Pre-Startup Safety ReviewINC: Incident Investigation
🔨 Safety Meeting Toolbox Talk
►What equipment have we reused in a new or harsher service?
►Which recurring problems have we learned to live with?
►Do our alarm responses include warning people in the area?
►What do our past incidents tell us about our next one?
Immediate Action Items
✓Review MOC and PSSR coverage for reused equipment.
✓Audit alarm response procedures for feed isolation and personnel warning.
✓Trend past incidents for repeat failure modes.
🔗 PSM Failures Behind This Incident

This incident involved breakdowns across 4 PSM-related areas (MI · SOP · PSSR · INC). Each represents a gap that process safety programs are designed to close.

Mechanical Integrity (MI)
Equipment must be designed, inspected, and maintained to operate safely in its intended service. Mechanical integrity failures contributed to loss of containment here.
Supporting documents in our library →
Operating Procedures (SOPs)
Operators cannot reliably hold safe operating limits without clear, current, enforced procedures. Deviation from acceptable operating conditions is a direct consequence of SOP failure.
Supporting documents in our library →
Pre-Startup Safety Review (PSSR)
New or modified equipment must be confirmed safe, built as designed, and covered by procedures and training before hazardous materials are introduced.
Supporting documents in our library →
Incident Investigation
Near-misses and prior incidents almost always signal the exact failure mode that eventually becomes fatal. When investigation is absent or superficial, those warnings go unheeded until consequences arrive.
Supporting documents in our library →
Process Safety Management Consulting & Document Library
📂
PSM Document Library
72 ready-to-deploy PSM documents covering all 14 OSHA elements — procedures, checklists, and audit templates built for facilities operating under 29 CFR 1910.119.
Browse the Library →
📊
Free PSM Health Score
Find out where your PSM program stands across all 14 OSHA elements. Our free health score surfaces your biggest gaps in under 10 minutes — no account required.
Check Your Score →
📞
Consulting Services
PHA facilitation, PSM program builds, compliance audits, and OSHA inspection support. Scoped per project with a written proposal before work begins — no retainer required to get started.
View Pricing →
📋 Explore the full incident library: All 111 CSB Case Studies →