Nitrogen Asphyxiation — Confined Space Opening
Valero Delaware City Refinery Asphyxiation Incident
Valero Delaware City Refinery
📍 Delaware City, DE
Incident: November 5, 2005 • CSB Report: November 2, 2006 (case study)
2
Fatalities
—
Injuries (not stated in CSB summary)
Nitrogen (Inert Purge Gas)
Chemical / Hazard
8
CSB Recommendations
📋 Incident Summary

On November 5, 2005, two contract workers were overcome by nitrogen and killed while doing maintenance near a 24-inch opening on top of a reactor at the Valero Delaware City Refinery. One of them died while attempting to rescue the other.

The CSB noted inadequate nitrogen asphyxiation hazard awareness training and improper confined space rescue actions. Its recommendations emphasize that an oxygen-deficient atmosphere overcomes a person rapidly and without warning, that it can exist outside a confined space opening, and that rescuers must strictly follow safe rescue procedures.

The CSB issued its case study and a safety video on November 2, 2006, with 8 recommendations.

🔎 Key Findings
Finding 01
Nitrogen Outside the Opening
Workers were overcome near the opening on top of the reactor, showing that an oxygen-deficient atmosphere can exist outside a confined space.
Finding 02
No Warning
Nitrogen overcomes people rapidly and without warning.
Finding 03
Fatal Rescue Attempt
The second worker died trying to rescue the first.
Finding 04
Permit and Warning Gaps
The CSB recommended better work permits that identify nitrogen purge status, and posted warnings, barricades, and access control at openings during purging.
🔍 Root Causes
1
Hazard not recognized
Workers did not recognize the nitrogen hazard near the opening.
2
Inadequate controls at the opening
Warnings and access controls around the opening were not maintained.
3
Unsafe rescue
An untrained, unprotected rescue led to a second death.
☑ CSB Recommendations
→ Valero Delaware City Refinery (2)
Provide safe work permit refresher training, including jobsite visits and nitrogen purge status, and confined space and inert gas purge refresher training.
→ Valero Energy Corporation (2)
Audit work permit and nitrogen purge procedures at all U.S. refineries, and revise nitrogen hazard awareness training.
→ Matrix Service Industrial Contractors (1)
Provide confined space and inert gas purge refresher training.
→ API, ASSE, and Compressed Gas Association (3)
Update guidance and issue alerts emphasizing that oxygen deficiency acts rapidly and without warning, can exist outside openings, and requires strict rescue procedures.

Full recommendation text and current status: CSB investigation page.

💡 Lessons Learned
Nitrogen gives no warning; one or two breaths can incapacitate.
Oxygen-deficient atmospheres can extend outside a vessel opening.
Never attempt a rescue without proper equipment and procedures.
Post warnings and control access at every opening during inert gas purging.
SOP: Operating ProceduresTRN: TrainingCON: ContractorsEAP: Emergency Planning
🔨 Safety Meeting Toolbox Talk
Topic: Nitrogen Asphyxiation & Confined Space Rescue Safety
►Where do we use nitrogen purging?
►How do we control access around openings on inerted equipment?
►What is our confined space rescue plan?
►Do contractors know the nitrogen hazard?
Immediate Action Items
✓Barricade and post warnings at openings of inerted equipment.
✓Review rescue plans and train on not entering without protection.
✓Add nitrogen purge status to work permits.
🔗 PSM Failures Behind This Incident

This incident involved breakdowns across 4 PSM-related areas (SOP · TRN · CON · EAP). Each represents a gap that process safety programs are designed to close.

Operating Procedures (SOPs)
Operators cannot reliably hold safe operating limits without clear, current, enforced procedures. Deviation from acceptable operating conditions is a direct consequence of SOP failure.
Supporting documents in our library →
Training & Operator Competency
Workers must understand process hazards — not just the steps on the page. Training records, refresher frequency, and verified competency are all OSHA PSM requirements.
Supporting documents in our library →
Contractors
Contractors must know the process hazards, and their safety performance must be part of how they are selected and overseen.
Supporting documents in our library →
Emergency Planning & Response
When process safety barriers fail, emergency response capability determines whether the outcome is controlled or catastrophic. Gaps in emergency preparedness amplified the consequences here.
Supporting documents in our library →
Process Safety Management Consulting & Document Library
📂
PSM Document Library
72 ready-to-deploy PSM documents covering all 14 OSHA elements — procedures, checklists, and audit templates built for facilities operating under 29 CFR 1910.119.
Browse the Library →
📊
Free PSM Health Score
Find out where your PSM program stands across all 14 OSHA elements. Our free health score surfaces your biggest gaps in under 10 minutes — no account required.
Check Your Score →
📞
Consulting Services
PHA facilitation, PSM program builds, compliance audits, and OSHA inspection support. Scoped per project with a written proposal before work begins — no retainer required to get started.
View Pricing →
📋 Explore the full incident library: All 111 CSB Case Studies →